When you think about Safeway cakes, the first word that comes to mind is value. You know you can count on Safeway when you learn that the company was founded more than a century ago.

Safeway bakery cakes are known for being affordable, but they’re also acclaimed for their amazing flavors, fillings, and designs. Thus, the Safeway cake designs and prices are both reasons for you to get excited about choosing this bakery. You can never go wrong with their products.

Learn everything you need to know about the cakes sold at Safeway in our complete guide.

Safeway Cake Prices

With over 900 stores throughout the United States, Safeway bakery provides customers with quality cakes at reasonable prices. So the most popular options for special occasions are the Safeway round cakes or sheet cakes.

The Safeway photo cakes, the Safeway custom cakes, and Safeway’s tres leches cakes are also in high demand for parties and special events.

But before you buy cakes from Safeway, check the approximate prices in the table below.

Safeway Round Cakes (8 inches) Prices
One-Layer Round Cake $9.99 – $12.99
Two-Layer Round Cake $15.99 – $19.99
Safeway Round Cakes (10 inches)
Two-Layered Round Cake $29.99
Safeway Cupcake Cakes
10-Cupcake Cake $6.99
24-Cupcake Cake $14.99
Safeway Sheet Cakes
1/8 Sheet Cake $10.99 – $16.99
1/4 Sheet Cake $24.99 – $37.99
1/2 Sheet Cake $34.99 – $49.99
Full Sheet Cake $55.99
Safeway Wedding Cakes
2-Tier Wedding Cake $91.30
3-Tier Wedding Cake $117.99

Safeway Cake Designs

Safeway’s cakes come in multiple styles and sizes. You have the traditional round cake, in one or two layers, the sheet cake that comes in a variety of sizes, but also some cakes specially designed for weddings, and cupcake cakes that are a novelty. It still depends on what you choose.

Thus, in terms of designs, the best part about buying a cake from Safeway is that you can customize it according to the celebration you need it for, and your preferences.

On the other hand, on the Safeway website, it is mentioned that you can pick from a variety of cakes they already have available, or choose to customize your own. Below, we will look at some cake designs that are suitable for occasions like birthdays, graduations, baby showers, and weddings.

Sizes and Shapes

Safeway cakes come in a wide variety of different sizes, but just four basic shapes. While, the least expensive of these cakes is the 8-inch round cake, and the most expensive of the cakes is the three-tier wedding cake. Safeway also sells cupcakes and sheet cakes as well.

Safeway also offers a cupcake cake. This is a new fad where a bunch of cupcakes is grouped on either a multi-tiered tray or a single tray, and they are decorated in a unified design to give the illusion that it is one big decorated cake.

Also, cupcake cakes tend to be a very popular option for children’s birthday parties, baby showers, and other parties alike. It offers cupcake cakes in batches of either twelve or twenty-four. You can choose the numbers depending on how much your event might need.

Safeway Birthday Cakes

Safeway’s cakes are great for birthday parties, regardless of age and gender. If you are celebrating a child, the birthday boy or girl will be thrilled to find a cake with their favorite cartoon characters illustrated on it, such as Cars, Barbie, or Angry Birds.

Nevertheless, Safeway cakes are just as great for those who have long passed childhood. No matter if you’re a preteen or a grandmother, you can enjoy a birthday cake from Safeway that is perfect for your personality and guests.

Safeway cakes birthday cake for adults

Furthermore, the cakes for birthdays can come in three forms: round, sheet, or cupcake cakes. Your round cake can have one or two layers, while sheet cakes are perfect for less hassle during the party. The ice cream cake Safeway bakes is also an excellent choice for a casual birthday party. Order your birthday cake now.

Safeway Graduation Cakes

Depending on the size of your graduation party, you can choose a Safeway round or sheet cake. Safeway has a wide range of cake flavors and fillings you can choose from. As well as Red velvet, German chocolate, lemon creme, midnight chocolate, white cake with white icing, or fruit layers for an awesome graduation cake.

A good idea is to choose a cake in the colors of the school, and add a graduation cap and a congratulatory message as decorations. A diploma for education, a cake for the celebration!

custom graduation cake

You should note, however, that it all depends on the specific Safeway bakery you are planning on visiting. Thus, the supply, variety, and even Safeway cake designs, flavors, fillings, and decorations all vary from retailer to retailer.

So, it is best to ask your local baker what Safeway custom cakes you can order.

Safeway Baby Shower Cakes

In the past few years, one of the most popular options for events like baby showers or friendly get-togethers is cupcake cakes. Depending on the size of your party, you can get a cupcake cake with either 10 or 24 cupcakes.

They look adorable, taste amazing, and are the icing on the cake (pun intended) for your baby shower.

Safeway cupcake cake for wedding

Of course, you can also go for a classic Safeway sheet cake. The sizes vary, so you should talk to your baker about which one would be appropriate for the number of guests you will have.

Customize the cake in baby blue or pink, according to the future child’s gender. You can choose your baby shower cake flavors and fillings, and add cute baby decorations to delight your guests. It will surely become an unforgettable party!

Safeway Wedding Cakes

If you want to tie the knot in style, a Safeway wedding cake can be the ideal addition to your wedding. What makes Safeway cakes stand out for weddings is their quality-price ratio, which is flawless.

Weddings are a substantial investment, and every penny you can save will be worth it in the end. As a result, you can cut costs without cutting the quality of your cake with one of the many Safeway cake options for weddings.

safeway cakes wedding cake

Like with most other bakeries, Safeway wedding cakes can have two or three tiers. However, if you are having a small wedding with just close friends and family members, you can always get a sheet or basic round cake. Still, if you have more than a handful of guests, it’s best to invest in one of their budget-friendly wedding cake options.

Pros and Cons of Choosing Safeway for Cakes

Safeway is rated very highly compared to many of its competitors in terms of the variety that they offer and the overall customizability of the cakes.

Safeway also offers various ways to order the cakes, for example by phone or directly in the store so this offers some versatility. With this in mind though, some people may prefer the simplicity of filling out an order form, which many competitors offer.

In regions where Safeway delivers groceries to your home, you can also get your cake delivered directly to your door. This is a very big advantage where available. Before ordering, be sure if you can get your cake delivered or whether it needs to be picked up from the store.

In terms of pricing, Safeway is on the higher end of the scale in comparison to its competitors. However, it is only Wal-Mart that edges Safeway in this regard.

This is because the other competitors offer less in terms of size and variety, and they also have limited options for customizability available compared to Safeway.

Suggested Read: Asda Cakes

How to Order Safeway Cakes

The only apparent downside to Safeway is that there is no cake ordering feature on their official website. If you are interested in a Safeway cake, it is best to visit or call your local bakery and order there directly. (kiiky.com)

You can talk to the decorators about how you want the final result to look, and other relevant details, such as preferred ingredients. To find the closest Safeway in your area, as well as their contact details, visit their store locator page.

You will find a full list of states that have Safeway stores. From there, you can select the city, address, and full details about their services. Make sure to check that the specific location has a bakery before visiting them.

Alternatively, if you want to see more Safeway cake designs before visiting the store, you can go to the order.cakes.com website, select the Safeway store closest to you, and look at the cakes listed there.

The website also includes an order form but doesn’t allow you to order the cakes online. What you can do, however, is print the order form and take it with you when you visit Safeway.


As you can see, one of the best things about Safeway is its variety, which is huge. If you are interested in ordering a Safeway cake, you can choose from options for children or adults, girls or boys, men or women.

As for wedding cakes, there are many budget-friendly options at Safeway. Have a splendid time at your special event, and let us know what you think of the Safeway cake prices and flavors down below! We would definitely love to hear from you!

You might also wanna check out related options like Walmart Cakes, Winn Dixie Cakes, Cami Cakes, and more.