Acme cake prices range from $8.99 to $54.99, depending on the specific product you are interested in. Compared to other bakers, Acme cakes are less expensive and larger. Acme cake designs work wonderfully for a wide range of memorable moments, from birthdays to weddings, graduations, or baby showers. Acme cakes are available on the northeast coast. Thus they usually have the same prices for basic cakes in all of their bakeries. Orders can be placed both online and in-stores, in one of their numerous locations. Find out more about Acme cakes prices, designs, ordering process, and more.

Acme Cakes Prices

In the table below, you will see prices for the entire selection of cakes Acme offers.

Round CakesPrices
1 layer$8.99
2 layer$14.99
Sheet Cakes
Character Designs 1/4 sheet$27.99
Character Designs 1/2 sheet$37.99
Character Designs Full sheet$54.99
Special Occasions 1/4 sheet$19.99
Special Occasions 1/2 sheet$28.99
Special Occasions Full sheet$47.99
Dessert Cakes
1 layer$12.99
2 layer$16.99
1/4 sheet$19.99
Cupcake Cakes
12 Count$8.99
24 Count$16.99

Note: Keep in mind that sometimes, the prices may vary from store to store. The prices showcased in the table above are for their Saddle Brook store.

Acme Cake Designs

One of the best things about Acme cakes is that you can customize them as you wish. They have a variety of flavors to choose from, and you can customize every last bit of the cake. From the flavor to the icing type, icing colors, and of course, the message you want to be printed on it.

While you can always choose one of their pre-made designs and still get a delicious cake, most people choose to customize their cake. The choice also depends on the amount of time you have to prepare for the celebration. If you need a cake ASAP, you can just pick one up at one of their locations. If you want to order a cake in advance, you can also discuss with their bakers for all customization options.

For instance, for their Chocolate Balloons Sheet Cake, you can choose from the following flavors: chocolate, marble, carrot, and yellow. In terms of icing, they offer buttercream, chocolate buttercream, whipped, chocolate whipped, cream cheese, and fudge. The borders and decorations can be pink, yellow, blue, purple, green, orange, black, red, white, and chocolate. Although you can also include a personalized message and special instructions.

Acme Birthday Cakes

Acme birthday cakes come in all sorts of shapes and sizes, fit for small and larger parties alike. In addition to this, Acme cakes for birthdays have designs that work well for adults, as well as children. Depending on the theme of your party, you can choose a lovely round cake design for a 12-guest party or a sheet cake with a character design.

There are plenty of cake designs to choose from, such as Butterfly or Daisies for women, or Plaid or Floating Balloons for men. You can customize your birthday cake, with options like flavor, icing type, icing colors, and message, just like in the image below.

Acme Cakes with a happy birthday message

Kids will enjoy cakes sporting their favorite characters. Designs like Thomas and Coal Car or Dinosaur Pals are perfect for little boys, while Dora the Explorer or Disney Princess Garden Royalty are ideal for girls. For parties with 15 to 20 guests, a ¼ sheet cake can be bought for $27.99. For 25 to 35 servings, go for a $37.99 ½ sheet cake. If you’re aiming for a big celebration, a full sheet character cake will serve 50 to 65 people, at the price of $54.99.

Acme Graduation Cakes

If you want to celebrate a recent graduate, you can always order a cake in the school’s colors, or topped with the mascot of the school’s sports team. Any other interest the graduate might have can also be represented on a cake, and so can a more traditional cap and gown illustration.

If you know the graduate won’t be a fan of these ideas, but you still want to celebrate their success, you can always go for a traditional cake. Acme has a great range of classic cakes as well, which are absolutely delicious, most notably the chocolate fudge cake pictured below.

Acme Cakes round chocolate cake

Acme Baby Shower Cakes

There is a multitude of Acme cakes appropriate for baby showers. First of all, the most popular design is their B-A-B-Y Blocks sheet cake. You can buy a small sheet cake (1/4) for $27.99, which will accommodate a party of 15-20. A ½ sheet cake at $37.99 works for 25 to 35 guests, while a full sheet costs $54.99, and provides 50 to 65 servings. Likewise, you can customize both the icing type and flavor.

Acme Cakes for baby shower

If you want something a bit more elegant, general, and ready-to-order, one of their dessert cakes is just what you need. Dessert cakes can be ordered either round or in sheet form, for prices that range from $8.99 for an 8-inch, single-layer dessert cake, to $19.99 for a ¼ sheet dessert cake. The first option serves 8, while the second is good for parties with 15 to 20 guests. Carrot, Cookies & Cream, and Fudge are just a few of the many options you have at hand.

Furthermore, a cupcake cake design can also be just what you need for a baby shower. Each pull-apart cupcake cake contains 15 cupcakes that can have yellow or chocolate filling. Their Elephant design is great for expecting a baby boy, while the Flowers version is a beautiful choice for a future baby girl.

Acme Wedding Cakes

Acme wedding cakes are both delicious and affordable at the same time. The ideal wedding option is a full-sheet special occasion cake. It only costs $47.99 and serves a small wedding of 50 to 65 guests. Depending on the design you choose, you can customize details that range from the flavor and fill to icing type, border, and decoration colors. Please note that some fillings might add $2.00 to your total price.

There isn’t any clear information about tier cakes on the Acme website. Nevertheless, we encourage you to speak to your local bakers about custom options that may be available. You might be able to order a 2- or 3-tier cake for a larger wedding. If not, you can always go for classic designs that fit the wedding theme, like this black and white cake with a bow on top.

stripped cake with red bow on top

Acme Bakery Prices

Acme does not only sell cakes, but also other baked goods, such as pastries, cookies, and cupcakes. The pastries come in trays, such as the Brownie Tray which contains 16 brownies and costs $9.99, the Italian Pastry Tray which has 30 assorted pastries and costs $19.99, or the Mini-Muffin Tray (48-count) for $18.99.

In terms of cookies, you can get cookie trays for prices ranging from $8.99 to $36.99, message cookies for $9.99, or sports design message cookies for prices ranging from $9.99 to $12.99. Acme also sells cupcakes. Character cupcakes, special occasion cupcakes, and sport design cupcakes cost $7.99-$14.99.

Recommended Read: Walmart Cake Prices, Designs, and Ordering Process

How to Order Acme Cakes

It’s easy to order Acme cakes online. All you have to do is visit their official website. Once you’re there, follow these simple steps:

  1. Press the click here link after you have read the message from the bakery.
  2. Choose the Store in your area.
  3. Click Start Shopping.
  4. Select the Cakes or Cupcake Cakes categories from the top menu.
  5. Choose your cake and start customizing it.
  6. Click Add to Cart and proceed to the checkout to complete your order.
order here

Alternatively, you can order Acme cakes over the phone by calling 1 877 276 9637. This is a more appropriate option for people who want a special design that they can’t find on the store’s website. In order to check if their bakers can make it, give them a call, or pay them a visit.


Acme cakes are a delightful choice for any special moment in your life or that of a loved one. With competitive prices, pretty designs, and plenty of custom options, you shouldn’t hesitate to choose an Acme cake for your next event if you live on the northeast coast. If you’ve ever had an Acme cake before, share your opinion of it down below. Don’t forget to also tell us what you think of the Acme cake prices.