Wegmans Cakes Prices, Designs and Ordering Process

Wegmans cakes are highly customizable to fit many special occasions, from birthday and graduation parties, to weddings and baby showers. Clients can simply create their own Wegman’s cakes online, in just a few clicks. Sizes available go from quarter sheet to round 2-layer. Wegman’s bakery offers multiple decorations, and delicious filling options, like raspberry or chocolate ganache. The Wegmans cakes flavors are the classical chocolate or vanilla, that never go out of style. If you have a favorite photo that you want to add to your special occasion cake, this is always possible with both the Wegmans celebration cakes, and cookie cakes. Learn more about the Wegmans cakes prices and designs below.

Wegmans Cakes Prices

The costs for Wegmans cakes begin at $9.00 for Ultimate Mini cakes, and go up to $42.00 for full sheet cookie cakes. Even though Wegmans bakery cakes prices can be different from one store to another, it’s usually only by 1-2 dollars. This might be owing to the fact that the bakeries are concentrated along the East Coast, in the following states:

  • Massachusetts;
  • Maryland;
  • New Jersey;
  • New York;
  • Pennsylvania;
  • Virginia;

Cake TypeSize
MA Price *NY Price **
Ultimate Mini Cake13 oz.$9.00 - $10.00$9.00 - $10.00
Ultimate Cake38 - 48 oz.$18.00$18.00
Round Cake1 layer$12.00$11.00
2 layer$17.00$17.00
Sheet Cake1/4 sheet$21.00$20.00
1/2 sheetN/A$34.00
Cookie Cake1/8 sheet$10.50$10.50
1/4 sheet$16.00$16.00
1/2 sheet$22.00$22.00
Full sheetN/A$42.00
Cupcakes12 pieces$13.00$13.00

*Prices for the Chestnut Hill store in Massachusetts.
** Prices for the Niagara Falls store in New York.

Wegmans Cakes Designs

Wegmans cake designs can be customized for an additional price, but their foundations are suitable for birthday parties, graduations, baby showers and other family gatherings. Their website doesn’t expand that much on Wegmans birthday cake designs, but you can ask your local bakery about specific options. After you create your Wegmans cake online, you will have to go to the closest store in your area to pickup your cake.

Wegmans Birthday Cakes

All Wegmans birthday cakes are customizable, both online, and in stores. For celebrating with close family or a few friends, you can get a round vanilla Wegmans birthday cake. A single-layer cake will cost $11.00 – $12.00, while a double-layer one will be $17.00 (both without custom options). If you choose to customize your birthday cake, Wegman’s offers decorations such roses, balloons, messages, and photos. These decorations are available on Wegmans sheet cakes.

The Ultimate Cakes at Wegmans are also a fantastic idea for a birthday party. A Wegmans Ultimate chocolate cake or white one will cost $18.00. When you go to any of the product pages for Wegmans cakes, you will see a full list of ingredients, allergens and nutrition facts. Additionally, you get a full list of Wegmans cakes reviews from customers that will help you make your final decision.

Wegmans Graduation Cakes

There are numerous graduation cake options at Wegmans. For instance, if you just want to congratulate the person who has graduated, you can get them a Mini Ultimate cake in chocolate, white or carrot with walnuts. The first two Wegmans cakes we mentioned will cost $9.00, while the carrot cake with walnuts will be $10.00 for the additional ingredients.

However, if you plan on celebrating with family and friends, a large ultimate cake might be more appropriate for serving your guests. Choose the graduate’s favorite flavor and get a 38 oz. (white) or 48 oz. (chocolate) cake for just $18.00.

If you plan on celebrating with the whole class, a Wegmans sheet cake will most likely work the best. Wegmans sheet cakes are available in ¼ sheet and ½ sheet sizes, both with buttercreme filling. A ¼ sheet cake costs between $20.00 and $21.00, while a ½ sheet one is $34.00 in select bakeries. For an extra fee, you can add a custom message to congratulate your grad.

Wegmans Baby Shower Cakes

One of the best ways to host a baby shower is to treat your guests to cake that reminds them of childhood. In this regard, we recommend a Wegmans cookie cake. The cookie cake Wegmans bakes is actually one of the store’s specialties, and comes in a variety of sizes. You pay $10.50 for an 1/8 sheet cookie cake, and $16.00 for a ¼ sheet. Larger Wegmans cookie cakes exceed $20.00, with a ½ sheet a $22.00 and a Wegmans full sheet at $42.00.

Of course, round Wegmans cakes always work wonderfully for baby showers as well. You can customize them with blue or pink frosting, depending on whether you’re expecting a baby girl or boy. Remember that you have both 1 layer and 2 layer options, for Wegmans cake prices that range from $11.00 – $17.00.

Wegmans Wedding Cakes

If you want a budget-friendly, and delicious option for your wedding, Wegmans is the bakery for you. Wegmans sheet cakes cost about $40, and are some of the best-tasting cakes available on the market. A pre-designed wedding cake from a similar bakery start at $150. For a smaller wedding, you can go for the Wegmans round cakes, which are equally delicious. So, you can discuss the decoration details and prices with your nearest Wegmans store. Before scheduling a tasting session, you can take look at our tips on picking the perfect wedding cake.

Wegmans Family Gathering Cakes

If you are looking for cake options for family gatherings, like holidays or reunions, Wegmans cupcakes are perfect. The best value is a family pack with 12 assorted cupcakes, which can be purchased for $13.00. This makes Wegmans cakes the less expensive alternative for competitors like Food Lion, which sell cupcake cakes from $16.00.

If you plan on preparing a few platters for a buffet, you can choose a pack of assorted mini cupcakes instead. On the other hand, if you are just having a friend or close family member over for a visit, a 4-pack of cupcakes will work just fine. Wegmans cupcakes are a colorful addition for any family get-together.

How to Order Wegmans Cakes?

Finally, we will cover the ordering process for Wegmans cakes. Customers can visit the online cake ordering page, or can order by telephone. If you prefer to call them instead of visiting a store, dial 1-800-914-GIFT (4438).

order here

Furthermore, here are the contacts for the two stores we used to create our Wegmans cakes price list:

Chestnut, Massachusetts

Address: 200 Boylston Street,

Chestnut Hill, MA 02467

Tel: (617) 762-2000

Niagara Falls, New York

Address: 1577 Military Road

Niagara Falls, NY 14304

Tel: (716) 298-3100

As for those who want to order face-to-face, they can find their nearest Wegmans cakes bakery with their store locator. Once you place your order, you will be able to speak with your local baker about custom options, delivery, or pick up times and other aspects relevant for your customer experience.


Whether you prefer the Wegmans round, sheet, or cupcakes, they are all a classy, tasty, and inexpensive option for your special occasion. The good part about the Wegmans cakes is that they are easily customizable, so you can really create the perfect cake for your party. What was your experience with Wegmans cakes? Have you ever ordered them for a birthday, wedding, or baby shower? Leave your comments below! We love to hear from you!


    • Ella Kool

Pin It on Pinterest