Pie in the Sky has got your gluten-free sweet needs covered with a delicious and colorful selection of pies, cheesecakes, and macaroons. They have something for every budget, every craving, and every occasion, ranging from sweet to savory. Get your sweet tooth on by the pie or cheesecake with Pie in the Sky cakes prices starting at an unbelievably economical $6.00 each. Their pies will fill your senses with gourmet and gluten-free taste for a budget-friendly price.

Why choose Pie in the Sky? Originating in Boulder, Colorado, their friendly bakers take pride in creating classic desserts with a gluten-free friendly recipe, without sacrificing the familiar, delicious taste. Unlike other gluten-free desserts sold at grocery stores, boutiques, and gourmet bakeries, they keep their quality high and their pricing low with six signature pies and cheesecakes, as well as a selection of macaroons. Buy a slice of heaven in store, or order a special occasion pie by visiting a Pie in the Sky location. Read on to learn more about the Pie in the Sky cakes designs and prices.

Pie in the Sky Cakes Prices

Pie in the Sky prides themselves in crafting gorgeous, tantalizing gluten-free desserts. Their owner is gluten-free himself, and aims to reinvent the way you eat dessert. Where many gluten-free versions of your favorites can be expensive or extremely difficult to find, Pie in the Sky aims to please.

Pie in the Sky cakes prices are truly a steal, especially considering that they’re handmade. See the chart below for a quick look at their pricing.

Type of cakePrice
Pies and Cheesecakes
Blueberry Cheesecake$6.00
Pumpkin Cheesecake$6.00
Traditional Cheesecake$6.00
Strawberry Cheesecake$6.00
Chocolate Cheesecake$6.00
Key Lime Pie$6.00

You can also order a multi-pack of 20 pies for $119.00 per pack. That brings Pie in the Sky cakes prices to just under $6.00 each – a true bargain! The multi-pack includes their Chocolate, Traditional, Key Lime, and Blueberry flavors. You can also choose your own flavors and mix and match. The multi-pack is a fantastic way to please a crowd at a get-together with family and friends, a holiday gathering, or even a baby shower.

Pie in the Sky Cake Designs

Pie in the Sky cakes prices are unbelievably budget-friendly. What is more, their pies and cheesecakes are suitable for holidays, birthdays, picnics, and other special occasions. At this time, Pie in the Sky’s macaroon selection is listed as “Coming Soon” on their website. We’re definitely looking forward to seeing what they come up with!

Give your birthday party, graduation party, baby shower, or wedding guests something a little bit different, but just as delicious, with one of Pie in the Sky’s several menu items. Their offerings can be adapted for any occasion and every craving. Each cheesecake is made with non-GMO ingredients, is 100 percent natural with no preservatives, is handmade, and 100 percent gluten-free — not to mention addictively delicious!

Pie in the Sky Birthday Cake

Sometimes an everyday birthday cake just won’t satisfy your sweet tooth. Pie in the Sky seems to specialize in gluten-free cheesecakes. However, you can adapt these treats to a birthday party, by ordering multiple items. A true delight is David’s signature, perfected gluten-free Key Lime Pie for only $6.00.

The Key Lime Pie is a creamy, sweet, and tart substitute for the classic birthday cake. When you taste it, you won’t believe that it’s gluten-free. Blow out the candles, and celebrate a new year with a healthy start! The Key Lime Pie is baked from scratch with non-GMO ingredients, is 100 percent natural with no preservatives, and is 100 percent gluten-free.

Pie in the Sky Graduation Cake

Pie in the Sky offers five cheesecakes that will take your graduation party to the next level. Even better, their gluten-free options taste just like the original thing:

  • Blueberry Cheesecake;
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake;
  • Traditional Cheesecake;
  • Strawberry Cheesecake;
  • Chocolate Cheesecake;

After David perfected his gluten-free Key Lime Pie, he knew he had to do the same for cheesecake. Just like with his Key Lime Pie, David experimented with each of his signature five flavors until they were rich and delicious gluten-free desserts.

If your graduate is looking for something sweet, their Blueberry and Strawberry Cheesecakes are guaranteed to please your sweet tooth. Want something savory? Try their creamy Pumpkin or Chocolate Cheesecake. If your graduate is a hardcore cheesecake traditionalist and only the original flavor will do, their Traditional Cheesecake will wow your taste buds . And Pie in the Sky cakes prices are sure to wow your wallet. You can also order a multi-pack and keep everyone at your graduation party happy.

Pie in the Sky Baby Shower Cake

At the time of this writing, David’s next challenge is achieving tasty, gluten-free macaroons. These handmade, lightweight cookies made with egg whites, sugar, and ground almonds or coconut look like mini sandwiches. They’re absolutely perfect for baby showers. Wow your guests with gender-specific pink or blue macaroons, or order a more gender-neutral array for dessert. Or fill a jar with multicolored macaroons and play the classic guess how many game with a modern twist.

Just like Pie in the Sky cakes prices, their macaroons are sure to be affordable. You can follow the progress on their  Facebook page. We definitely think David will wow us when his macaroons are available! Another great option is to make a dessert buffet with strawberry cheesecakes, for a girl gender reveal party.

Pie in the Sky Wedding Cake

More and more couples are eschewing the traditional two- or three-layer wedding cake for something more unique and fun. With candy buffets as take-home favors all the rage, you can implement this modern concept into your wedding with a pie buffet. Order one of Pie in the Sky’s multi-packs, and arrange your serve-yourself table with all six of their cheesecake and pie options. Or put a modern twist on the layered cake with a multi-layer stand displaying your favorite cheesecake flavor. Your cake cutting ceremony — and the requisite cake-in-the-face photo op — will be even more memorable with one of David’s cheesecakes or pies.

How to Order Pie in the Sky Pies and Cakes

To order a pie or cheesecake from Pie in the Sky, you can order online through their website by viewing their pies and cheesecakes menu.

order here

You can also visit one of nine grocery stores all over the country, such as Whole Foods in the Rocky Mountain region, or King Soopers in Colorado, Wyoming, and New Mexico. View all of their locations on their website. For further questions, contact them by email, at david@pieintheskybakery.com.


Whether you’re looking for something different to help celebrate a momentous birthday, baby shower, or wedding, Pie in the Sky is a heavenly crowdpleaser that will make your special day extraordinary. Have you ever ordered the delicious Pie in the Sky cakes? Share your experience with us in the form below. We love to hear from our readers!