Cold Stone Cream Creamery offers, as they pride themselves, the ultimate ice cream experience. Cold Stone cakes are layered with creamy, rich, and delicious ice cream. Also, customers can choose a yummy Cold Stone ice cream cake with white frosting or rich fudge ganache. Moreover, there is a wide variety of Cold Stone creamery cakes, from birthday cakes, signature cakes, and custom cakes to kid-themed cakes, petite cakes, and ice-cream cupcakes.

Cold Stone Creamery ice cream cakes can be found all across the United States but also internationally. So, learn more about Cold Stone prices and designs and how you can order Cold Stone cakes below.

Cold Stone Cakes Prices

Small Cold Stone cakes typically range from $24.99 to $55.00, depending on shape (round or rectangle) and location. Large Cold Stone Creamery cakes are priced between $36.49 and $81.00, based on the aforementioned factors. Even though the average Cold Stone Creamery cake is more expensive than one from Baskin Robbins (one of their top ice cream cake competitors), thus, it shines through variety, quality, and taste.

The prices for Cold Stone birthday cakes vary from location to location. In order to help you get a better idea about Cold Stone cake prices, we have included examples from two stores on different coasts. As a result, below, you will find the Cold Stone ice cream cake prices from a New York location and a California one.

Cold Stone Cakes DesignCold Stone Prices NYCold Stone Prices NYCold Stone Prices CACold Stone Prices CA
Small Round
6" - Serves 8
Small Rectangle
8" x 12" - Serves 25
Small Round
6" - Serves 8
Small Rectangle
8" x 12" - Serves 25
Cake Batter Confetti$24.99$48.99$35.00$55.00
Midnight Delight$24.99$48.99$35.00$55.00
Cookie Dough Delirium$24.99$48.99$35.00$55.00
Cookies & Creamery$24.99$48.99$35.00$55.00
Strawberry Passion$24.99$48.99$35.00$55.00
MMMMMMint Chip$24.99$48.99$35.00$55.00
A Kiss of StrawberryN/AN/A$35.00$55.00
A Cheesecake Named DesireN/AN/A$35.00$55.00
Chocolate ChipperN/AN/A$35.00$55.00
Peanut Butter PlaygroundN/AN/A$35.00$55.00
Create your cake - Multiple Options$30.99$54.99$35.00$55.00
Custom Birthday
Quilted Coffee Caramel N/A$43.99
Cake Batter LayersN/A$43.99
6 Cupcakes
Sweet Cream (x2)
Cake Batter Deluxe (x2)
Double Chocolate Devotion (X2)

* Cold Stone Creamery Prices at the Atlantic Mall location: 139 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn, NY. Phone: (718) 230-1562.

** Cold Stone Creamery Prices at USC: 3730 South Figueroa Street, Los Angeles, CA. Phone: (213) 747-2744.

Cold Stone Cakes Designs

Ice cream cakes cover the following main categories:

  • Birthday Cakes (Theme or Custom)
  • Signature Cold Stone Cakes
  • Cupcakes (Signature or Custom)

Regardless if you want to get a  birthday cake, a famous signature cake, or a pack of mouth-watering cupcakes, you can count on Creamery to meet your tasty celebration needs.

The  Creamery ice cream cake can be adapted to any occasion. Also, the ice cream cake offers come in various shapes and sizes, including the following:

  • Petite – 4″ – serves 2
  • Small Round – 6″ – serves 8
  • Large Round – 8″ – serves 14
  • Small Rectangle – 8″ x 12″ – serves 25
  • Large Rectangle – 12″ x 18″ – serves 50

You can get round or rectangle cakes for occasions like:

  • Birthdays
  • Graduations
  • Baby showers
  • Holidays
  • Family reunions, etc.

In addition to this, you can customize a cake according to the details of your event or order a 6 pick of cupcakes. We’ll get into specifics about what cakes work for certain occasions below.

Cold Stone Cakes – Birthday Cakes


If you or an adult friend are planning to celebrate a birthday, cakes are a refined and delicious option. Even though flavors, ingredients, and custom options vary depending on the store, you can pick the ice cream flavor and cake layer. Sweet Cream or Cake Batter Ice Cream are some wonderful choices for ice cream flavor. Also, you can explore Yellow or Red Velvet cake layer options at some stores. A small round cake costs between $24.99 and $35.00 and serves 8.


Themed cakes are the most popular cakes for children. From Spiderman and SpongeBob SquarePants to Avengers or Disney Princesses, you will most likely find the perfect option for your child. But, themed cakes cannot be ordered online on the cakes website. Also, the reason is that toys, designs, and availability vary depending on location. If you want a themed cake for your child’s birthday, contact your local Creamery.

Cold Stone Cakes – Graduation Cakes

Although they do not have a special graduation cake, the Signature cakes like Midnight Delight, Cookie Dough Delirium, or Cake Batter Confetti can be adapted for graduations, family celebrations, holidays, and more. When you order online, you get to choose special messaging and its color, like pink, blue or red. A 4″ Petite cake that serves 2 is perfect for a romantic celebration, while a Large Rectangle (12″ x 18″) serves 55 and is ideal for large gatherings.

Cold Stone Cakes – Baby Shower Cakes

The cute cupcakes make perfect baby shower cakes. While some cake stores offer signature cupcake packs with 2 each of their well-known varieties, others provide custom options for cupcake orders. Their signature designs are Sweet Cream, Cake Batter Deluxe, and Double Chocolate Devotion. The custom cupcake option allows you to choose the ice cream flavor (like Cheesecake Ice Cream), cake layer (like Devil’s Food Cake), and frosting (Fluffy White or other colors).

Cold Stone Cakes – Wedding Cakes

The only category the Creamery doesn’t seem to cover is wedding cakes, but you should check with your local store to see if they can make one for your reception. Contact your nearest location to see if it is possible to order a wedding cake.

How to Order Cold Stone Cakes

You can order online or visit one of their cake locations to speak directly with a representative. Also, to order cakes online, go to the order page. Then, enter your ZIP code and see what location is closest to your area. And this is the same page where you will get the working hours and contacts for your nearest store. After that, choose your desired cake category (like Signature Cakes, Ready for Pick Up Now, or Create Your Own Cake) and select the specifics:

  • Shape
  • Size
  • Ice cream flavor
  • Cake layer
  • Frosting, etc.

order here


To conclude,  cakes are a refined choice for any celebration with your loved ones. The ice cream sets them apart from numerous other competitors in their field, as well as the abundance of ingredients (like candies). So, even though they might be pricier than others, the final result is worth the money.