Bruster’s stands out from other ice cream shops because they make all of their ice cream freshly and on-site every day. This might seem expensive and gourmet, but Bruster’s ice cream is still surprisingly affordable. Depending on what you pick, Bruster’s ice cream prices range from $2 to $6, and they have many flavors and different ice cream variants to try. In this article, we will share information about the types of ice cream treats sold at Bruster’s. We will give details on flavors and toppings, and let you know how much everything costs.

Bruster’s Ice Cream Prices

Bruster’s Ice Cream
Waffle Cone (2 scoops) $3.77
Waffle Cone (3 scoops) $4.44
Waffle Cone (4 scoops) $5.37
Cake Cone (2 scoops) $2.82
Cake Cone (3 scoops) $3.87
Cake Cone (4 scoops) $4.91
Cup (2 scoops) $2.82
Cup (3 scoops) $3.87
Cup (4 scoops) $4.91
Bruster’s Sundaes
Classic Sundae $4.25
Brownie Sundae $5.61
Banana Split Sundae $5.61
Turtle Sundae $4.95
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae $4.95
Kids Sundae $2.83
Bruster’s Ice Cream Drinks
Milkshake (regular) $4.25
Milkshake (large) $5.42
Blast (regular) $4.24
Blast (large) $5.19
Bruster’s Ice Cream Cakes
8 Inch Round $25.95
¼ Sheet Cake $38.95

Bruster’s Ice Cream Flavors

Bruster’s has an extensive list of ice cream flavors, so each store rotates through different options. Flavors at Bruster’s include banana, birthday cake, black cherry, blueberry cheesecake, butter pecan, caramel, cherry, chocolate, cookie dough, Oreo, peanut butter, snickerdoodle, strawberry, turtle, vanilla, and white almond. Some flavors, such as black raspberry, peach, pumpkin, and peppermint may only be available during certain seasons.

Customers who want something a little healthier can order one of the no-sugar added flavors, such as chocolate, coffee, vanilla, strawberry, or caramel. They also have frozen yogurt versions of most of their flavors for a lower-fat option, and those who are avoiding dairy can order their ices or sherbets. All Bruster’s flavors can be purchased in a two scoop, three scoop, or four scoop size. The Bruster’s ice cream prices for cake cones or cups range between $2.82 and $4.91 depending on size, and each size of waffle cone is a few cents extra.

Bruster’s Ice Cream Toppings

Bruster’s has many delicious toppings available. Standard toppings are whipped cream, cherries, nuts, or sprinkles. Customers can pick from many types of sauce, including chocolate, caramel, strawberry, marshmallow, peanut butter, pineapple, and butterscotch.

Gourmet toppings include candy bits, cookies, and brownies. Most of these toppings are included in the Bruster’s ice cream prices for items like sundaes or blasts, but sometimes you can pay a little extra to get them added to other menu items.

Bruster’s Sundaes

Bruster’s has many delicious sundaes for customers to pick from. You can get a classic sundae with whipped cream, cherries, nuts, and your choice of chocolate, caramel, strawberry, marshmallow, peanut butter, pineapple, or butterscotch sauce for just $4.25.

For $5 to $5.50, customers have the option of ordering a more gourmet ice cream sundae with additional sauces and toppings. This includes even more extras, such as chunks of candy, brownies, apple dumplings, or strawberry shortcake. For younger customers, Bruster’s has kids’ sundaes for $2.83. These come with a fun dinosaur cookie, or a mixture of Oreo crumbles and gummy worms.

Bruster’s Ice Cream Cakes

If you want to celebrate a birthday or other special occasion, Bruster’s offers ice cream cakes as well. These are typically a layer of any flavor of Bruster’s ice cream on top of a cake, decorated with frosting and a coat of vanilla ice cream. You can add a middle layer of fudge, caramel, marshmallow, or any other Bruster’s topping, and cake flavors are chocolate, vanilla, or yellow.

There are many great designs to choose from, including flowers, balloons, celebratory streamers, cherries, or ice cream cones. Bruster’s will also write a customized message on the top of any ice cream cake for you. You can get an 8 inch round cake that serves 16 people for $25, or you can get a quarter sheet cake that serves 24 for $38.95. Bruster’s recommends that you call your local Bruster’s at least 48 hours in advance to order a cake.

Bruster’s Frozen Treats

Other frozen treats at Bruster’s are ice cream drinks, ice cream pies, or specially blended ice cream mixes. Bruster’s freshly made milkshakes cost $4.25 for a regular or $5.42 for a large. They come in vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry variants made with fresh Bruster’s ice cream.

A Bruster’s Blast is somewhat like a milkshake, but its texture is a little thicker, and it contains more ingredients. A Blast is the same price as a milkshake, but it is made from vanilla ice cream blended with your choice of Oreo cookies, Twix, M&Ms, Reese’s cups, brownie chunks, cookies, Snickers, Heath Bars, or butterfingers. If you want a treat that will serve six people, you can buy an ice cream pie. This is your choice of Bruster’s ice cream layered on your choice of Bruster’s topping, inside of a graham cracker or Oreo pie crust.

Where to Find Bruster’s Ice Creams

You can find Bruster’s ice cream at any one of their restaurants. Enter your location in the Bruster’s store locator to find one near you. To learn more about the Bruster’s ice cream prices, use one of these methods to get in touch with the company.

Bruster’s Phone Number: 724-774-4250
Bruster’s Official Website
Bruster’s Contact Page
Bruster’s Address: Bruster’s Real Ice Cream
730 Mulberry St.
Bridgewater, PA 15009

The freshly made ice cream at Bruster’s is available in many tasty flavors, and at under $6 for any menu item, the Bruster’s ice cream prices are quite affordable. What is your favorite flavor of ice cream sold at Bruster’s? Write a comment below to share your opinion with us!

Recommended Read: Haagen Dazs Ice Cream Prices & Flavors