BJ’s cakes are an affordable option for those who want amazing ready-to-order or customizable desserts for their special occasions. The prices for BJ’s cakes will start at around $15.99 for a 10-inch round cake.
You also have a variety of available fillings and can completely customize your cake from the inside out. Depending on what you need a cake for, the BJ’s bakery offers photo cakes, theme cakes, two-tiered cakes, decoration packets, and more.
Read on to learn more about BJ’s cakes prices and designs. See how to customize them for birthdays, graduations, baby showers, weddings, or other special events in your life.
A Bit About BJ’s Bakery
BJ’s Bakery Wholesale Club was founded in 1984 as an off-shoot of the Zayre department store. This first store was located in Medford in Massachusetts. BJ’s is currently owned by two private equity firms. If you wish to shop at BJ’s, you must become a member of the BJ’s Wholesale Club.
BJ’s currently has 216 locations which can be found across sixteen states along the east coast of the United States. The clubs currently inhabit as far west as Ohio.
In addition to the locations in Ohio and Massachusetts, there is also at least one BJ’s in the following states: New Hampshire, Maine, Connecticut, Rhode Island, Delaware, New Jersey, New York, Maryland, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, South Carolina, Florida, Georgia, and Virginia.
If you live outside of these states, unfortunately, you are out of luck. There are also currently no BJ’s stores outside of the United States.
Every BJ bakery is a full-service operation. At most of BJ’s locations, bakers make cakes, pies, bagels, cookies and other baked treats on a daily basis. BJ’s also employs cake decorators who are always available in store to add a personal touch to cakes and many other baked goods.
The bakery sells goods from the company’s own store brands which are Wellesley Farms and Berkley-Jensen but BJ’s also offers products from well-known national brands such as Pepperidge Farm, Old El Paso, Thomas, and Pillsbury.
If you seek to buy only organic products or natural goods then you can purchase those products under popular brands, such as Amy’s Kitchen, Kashi, Newman’s Own, Kerrygold, and American Flatbread. All of these can be found in nearly all BJ’s stores.
But before shopping at BJ’s, you must first become a member of the club. Memberships are available for both business users and personal users but prices may vary.
BJ’s Bakery Specifications
Number of Locations: 216 (as of 2018)
Bakery Type: Wholesale
Open to General Public: No
Notice For Special Personalized Items: 2 days
Bakery Offerings: Cakes, bagels, pastries, pies, other baked goods
Bj’s bakeries are located within a large wholesale club which is open only to the members of the club. BJ’s customers can purchase all different types of baked goods from the bakery.
Some of these items include pies, cakes, bagels, donuts, bread, buns, pastries, among other items. BJ’s bakery employs professional cake decorators who can fully customize any of the baked goods that they sell.
If you would like to purchase a special item such as a wedding cake, you must give the bakery department an advance notice of this. In most BJ’s clubs, a couple of days is sufficient time for them to create the item that you order.
When you order baked goods, you can choose quantities, styles, flavors, and all other features and get assistance from BJ’s bakery staff members. Depending on the size of your order, you may be required to pay a deposit upon ordering.
BJ’s bakeries have their separate location within the larger wholesale store. Most of them have a unique trade dress in order to separate them from the other sections of the club.
The bakery staff display the baked goods behind counters. Some of the items are self-serve, however, other items require assistance from a bakery staff member.
BJ’s bakery has two house brands of their baked goods. These are Berkley-Jensen and Wellsley Farms. Most of the products from these brands are pre-made, pre-packaged, and delivered to the BJ’s store via a truck. The bakery within BJ’s does, however, have its own kitchen where some of the baked goods are made in-store.
The difference between the pre-made products and the in-store-made products is usually evident in the packaging that is used. If a product has no packaging, this has usually been made by one of the bakers in the store.
The BJ’s bakery does sell other name-brand goods too. Some of the name-branded goods on offer include cakes, cookies, bagels, tortillas, and pastries – all from national brands.
These items are usually shelved within and surrounding the bakery. Usually, the products that are from well-known brands come in large or bulk packaging.
BJ’s Cake Prices
|¼ sheet cake (serves 12-16) – gold cake and vanilla mousse filling w/ buttercream icing||$16.99|
|¼ sheet cake (serves 12-16) – marble cake and chocolate mousse filling w/ non-dairy whipped topping||$16.99|
|10" round cake (serves 18-24) – marble cake and buttercream filling w/ buttercream icing||$15.99|
|½ sheet cake (serves 20-30) – gold cake and strawberry mousse filling w/ non-dairy whipped topping||$23.99|
|½ sheet cake (serves 20-30) – marble cake and strawberry mousse filling w/ non-dairy whipped topping||$23.99|
|½ sheet cake (serves 20-30) – marble cake and chocolate mousse filling w/ non-dairy whipped topping||$23.99|
|½ sheet cake (serves 20-30) – ½ gold cake and ½ chocolate cake w/ buttercream icing and no filling||$23.99|
|Full sheet cake (serves 60-75) – ½ gold cake and ½ chocolate cake w/ buttercream icing and no filling||$39.99|
|Full sheet cake (serves 60-75) – gold cake w/ buttercream icing and no filling||$39.99|
|Wellsley Farms 12-pack cupcakes - gold cake or|
chocolate cake w/ white frosting
BJ’s Cake Designs
When shopping for a cake at BJ’s, you can choose from a variety of licensed character cakes, seasonal cakes, and specialty cakes with various flavors and frostings. BJ’s cakes are well suited for special occasions like birthdays, graduation parties, baby showers, and even weddings.
You can browse through a variety of cake styles. Alternatively, you can pick out a cake that is tailored to match up with your party.
On the BJ’s Party Planning Brochure, you can learn more about the cake sizes offered by BJ’s, as well as the fact that BJ’s offers customization options for free. You can choose the flavors, frostings, and fillings of your choice, choose a Photo Cake, theme cake, two-tiered cake, or decoration packet for no additional charge.
BJ’s Birthday Cakes
Whether it is for a child or an adult, BJ’s cakes are just right to celebrate any special birthday. For a child birthday party, you can pick from a variety of decoration packets, to include licensed characters or a range of popular children’s themes.
All cake decorating sets for birthday and theme cakes are going to be subject to availability. So, be sure to check with a BJ’s team member whether the theme cake decorating set you would like is available.
For the birthday of an adult, you can go with a round cake with your choice of fillings. Alternatively, you can have a larger sheet cake for serving anywhere between 12 to 75 guests.
If you have a particular photograph of the special birthday guest of honor, you can also have a custom Photo Cake. Don’t forget to select a photo that has a crisp image to have the best result. We recommend consuming the Photo Cake on the day of the pickup, so that you can retain the image quality.
BJ’s Graduation Cakes
BJ’s can come up with just about any sort of graduation cake that you desire. Colored frostings can match the colors of the school where the guest of honor is graduating from. It is also easy to have a number of cupcakes made up in matching colors. They are great for the guests to grab and go in favor boxes.
A BJ’s marble cake and chocolate mousse filling 1/4 sheet cake that serves 12 to 16 guests can take the center stage of a graduation party. Ask the bakery if they can customize the cake with a graduation cap, diploma, message, or photo, to better fit the party theme.
BJ’s Baby Shower Cakes
Regardless as to whether or not there is a boy or a girl on the way, or even twins, the BJ’s bakery staff can come up with an incredible cake. At BJ’s, you can find the right cake for the theme of your baby shower.
Are you planning a gender reveal party? The bakers can come up with BJ’s cakes or cupcakes that have a secret color inside. The guests can dive into all at once to get to know whether the baby is a boy or a girl.
BJ’s Wedding Cakes
There is never any need to spend a fortune on a wedding cake when you can find one at BJ’s that is going to taste great and look amazing. BJ’s offers a range of two-tiered cakes that are just perfect for a wedding.
For more guests than the two-tier cake serves, you can add on another sheet cake in your choice of matching flavors. That one will be served to all of your guests after you use your showpiece cake for cutting.
All you have to do is inquire about the special pricing of custom two-tier BJ’s cakes. You might be amazed at the savings you will be able to enjoy. However, before deciding, you can also take a look at other great options for wedding cake bakeries.
BJ’s Bakery Prices
Apart from the custom BJ’s cakes you have to order in advance, you can also find pre-made cakes and other bakery treats in any BJ’s location. Among the delicios desserts you can find at BJ’s are brownies, crumb cakes, mousse, pies, loaf cakes, cheesecakes, tea cakes, and more.
In terms of pre-made cakes, we recommend the popular Wellsley Farms 7″ Chocolate Bavarian Cake, Wellsley Farms 3-Layer 9″ Cookies & Cream Cake, or Wellsley Farms 7″ Chocolate Truffle Bomb Cake.
The prices for these items are not specified, since you have to visit a BJ’s location to purchase them.
BJ’s Bakery Pros and Cons
- Huge Selection
- Affordable Pricing
- On-site Decorator
One of the biggest advantages of purchasing cakes from BJ’s bakery is the fact that they have an on-site decorator on hand. Many of the cakes that BJ’s sells come with decorations already on them, however, these aren’t personalized.
In most places, a decorator can add a personal touch to your cake while you shop. This is a benefit of BJ’s bakery that makes it very appealing for busy people who don’t have the time to work with a private decorator.
A further benefit to buying from BJ’s is the huge selection of bakery items. They offer such a wide selection that you’ll be spoilt for choice! This includes more than just cakes.
Additionally, BJ’s offers one-stop shopping. You can pick up your baked goods at the same time as picking up all of the general household items that you need.
Finally, BJ’s also offers extremely affordable prices for basically all of their bakery options. Of course, you need to pay an initial membership fee, however, once you’ve done this you’ll typically save around 20 to 50 percent on all of your bakery products.
If at any time you are unhappy with your BJ’s membership, you can ask for a refund of the remaining balance. It’s worth giving it a try for the savings.
- Average Quality
- Limited Locations
- Membership Requirements
If you are not a big fan of wholesale clubs, then you won’t be impressed by the BJ’s membership structure. It’s simply impossible to walk into a BJ’s store and pick up a cake without buying an initial membership.
However, you may be able to take advantage of a one-day membership if you simply would like to sample some of the cakes on offer before you commit to a full BJ’s membership.
The majority of the baked goods at BJ’s taste great, however, they don’t always look that great. A lot of online reviewers of the goods have expressed their disappointment in the quality that goes into the in-store decorating of baked goods.
Many people call the decorations amateur. If you are looking for something especially special and intricate, it is probably best to go elsewhere as you may be disappointed by what BJ’s offers.
Finally, BJ’s only have 216 locations on the east coast of the United States. If you live anywhere outside of the sixteen states where these stores are located, you won’t be able to shop there.
How To Order BJ’s Cakes
For any custom order BJ’s cakes, it is important that you allow at least 24-hour notice to ensure your cake will be decorated to your exact specifications. If you need to place an order in under 24 hours, inquire directly with one of the BJ’s team members.
You can reach the bakery by phone at (877) 257-3373 to place your order. You can also print out a form online and then take it to the bakery. To make it even easier, you can order custom cakes decorated to your liking online using the online decorating form.
You simply put in your member number, name, phone number, email, city and state, pickup date and time, and the cake type, trim color, writing color, and the message on the cake.
For online forms, allow at least 36 hours for your order to be processed. The BJ’s bakery order team is available from Monday to Saturday from 9 AM to 7 PM, and Sunday from 9 AM to 6PM ET. For Photo Cakes, you are required to print out the order form and bring it to the bakery at least 36 hours before pickup.
There are great BJ’s cakes waiting for you to celebrate any occasion imaginable. From fillings and frostings to a variety of decorating styles and sizes of cakes, you have the ability to create a delicious, custom cake that will leave a lasting impression on your guests.
No matter the occasion, you can pick out an affordable and tasty cake that will become quite the showpiece for your birthday party, graduation, promotion, wedding, baby shower, bridal shower, or any other sort of celebration. Tell us what you think of the BJ’s cake prices and designs down below.
Recommended Read: Costco Cakes Prices, Designs, and Ordering Process